ResearchWorks Archive

Confronting value strain: press coverage of health care reform in Sweden and the United States

Show simple item record Holmberg, Susan L. (Susan Lee) en_US 2009-10-07T02:24:41Z 2009-10-07T02:24:41Z 1999 en_US
dc.identifier.other b43902996 en_US
dc.identifier.other 43983078 en_US
dc.identifier.other Thesis 48878 en_US
dc.description Thesis (Ph. D.)--University of Washington, 1999 en_US
dc.description.abstract This comparative content analysis study examines the health care reform debates that took place in the early 1990's in Sweden and the United States in an effort to understand the role that cultural values might play in shaping news narratives about policy reform. In both countries, proposals for health care reform seem to manifest core value strain (seen here in terms of an individualist-collectivist spectrum) in the sense that calls for change both question prevailing institutional arrangements and challenge prevailing notions about how health care should be organized. Thus, in the US, Clinton's proposal for universal coverage challenged predominant values associated with individual freedom and choice, while in Sweden, proposals for increased privatization challenged the predominance of more collectivist values associated with health care security and collective responsibility.The study asks whether individualist values appear to be privileged in the US news narrative and whether collectivist values appear to be privileged in the Swedish news narrative. It offers the hypothesis of a cultural filter through which values may pass into the news. Accepting the possibility that among western liberal democracies, certain values are held more deeply by the general public and legitimized through institutional configurations more than others, it is proposed that value differences are likely to be observable at the national level which override differences at the institutional, organizational and individual levels.The overview of media and policy environments confirms cultural filter expectations, as both the media and health care norms and institutions appear to manifest clearly distinctive patterns reflecting the prominence of collective values in Sweden and individual values in the US. The content analysis of the news narrative presented in The New York Times, USA Today, Dagens Nyheter and Expressen further confirms the hypothesis, as the narrative profiles and patterns of value expression at the country level far outweigh distinctions at the organizational (elite/mass paper) or individual (journalist/actor "voice") levels. en_US
dc.format.extent vii, 194 p. en_US
dc.language.iso en_US en_US
dc.rights Copyright is held by the individual authors. en_US
dc.rights.uri For information on access and permissions, please see en_US
dc.subject.other Theses--Political science en_US
dc.title Confronting value strain: press coverage of health care reform in Sweden and the United States en_US
dc.type Thesis en_US

Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Search ResearchWorks

Advanced Search


My Account